Medicare Secondary Payer Myths: The Misconceptions Every Plaintiff Attorney Should Know Part 2

Medicare protects its best interests through the Medicare Secondary Payer (MSP) statute, which mandates that settlement funds are used before Medicare starts paying any bills.

If the government’s interests are not protected, Medicare can place a lien on your client’s settlement funds. Medicare lien resolution is complex, so outsourcing to experts can save time and resources while allowing you to do what you do best.

This is a two-part article that began with Medicare Secondary Payer Myths: The Misconceptions Every Plaintiff Attorney Should Know Part 1.

Myth #4- Medicare Never Actually Enforces its Rights

This myth used to be somewhat true in the past; however, most industry experts agree that Medicare has been monitoring MSA accounts far more over the last few years and will continue to do so.

The federal MSP statute gives Medicare the fundamental right to deny care and remain the secondary payer, and Medicare will make use of this right. Though there are no known litigated cases that have been brought against Medicare for cutting off benefits after discovering misuse of MSA funds, this does not mean that it is not regularly making denials of care.

It is dangerous to assume that Medicare will not monitor a given MSA account. Medicare has been keeping an eye on workers compensation cases and has also indicated that it plans to institute a review process for liability cases. If Medicare finds that its funds have been misused, it will put a lien on your client’s settlement, which will require lien resolution. Outsourcing this task can save time and resources.

Myth #5- Clients Can Obtain Different Insurance After They Settle

Many attorneys assume that their clients do not have to worry about a Medicare set-aside allocation because they can simply switch to a different insurance provider after they settle. This is not the case.

First of all, most insurance carriers include exemptions for care relating to settled claims. That’s not to say your client has no chance of getting another entity to cover their injury, but it comes with risks. When it comes to MSAs, switching to another insurance plan may seem like it can preserve some of the funds, and this could be true in the short term. However, long-term consequences may rear their heads; for example, your client may need to spend MSA funds to cover their new plan’s premiums or deductibles, putting them out of compliance with Medicare guidelines.

Complying with Medicare’s best interests is complex and outsourcing to professionals can save time and resources. If you are in need of Medicare lien resolution services, we can help.

For more information or to schedule a consultation, please submit our contact request form.

Disclaimer: The information contained in this article is for general educational information only. This information does not constitute legal advice, is not intended to constitute legal advice, nor should it be relied upon as legal advice for your specific factual pattern or situation.


"Synergy has been a trusted part of our legal team for many years. They have helped our clients in many cases to understand the benefits of structured settlements. Synergy has protected our clients and us by securing the best annuities on the market with the safest companies available. Our Synergy consultant is a great communicator in explaining the details and benefits of structured settlements to our clients. He has also mentored myself and the other lawyers in our firm in the benefit of Attorney Fee Annuities. Their work with our firm has secured our clients and our financial security and we expect to continue working with him for many years to come."

Brett Panter
Panter, Panter & Sampedro

"Coincidentally, on the day of a recent Synergy Seminar on Medicare & ERISA lien resolution I received a letter on an ERISA lien. This letter followed much back and forth between myself and the recovery vendor for BCBS. Despite my efforts they were adamant there would be no (zero)(zilch)(nada) reduction and provided case law to support their position. I tried Synergy’s Lien Resolution Services since I had just heard their Director of Lien Resolution speak. Synergy got them to reduce their claim by a third in less than ten (10) days. The result was quick and the fee very reasonable. If you have a tough ERISA lien and your typical efforts don’t work, give Synergy a try."

Michael S. Smith, Esq.
Lesser, Lesser, Landy & Smith, PLLC

WordPress Image Lightbox